Betfair and TAB Trade Claims Over One Pool Win Dividends
Betfair and Tabcorp are arguing in public over whether the new One Pool national tote pays competitive win dividends. Betfair published a comparison claiming its Starting Price (BSP) beat the One Pool win dividend on 391 of 553 winners – 70.7 per cent – across 551 Australian thoroughbred races between 3 and 12 October. Tabcorp chief executive Gillon McLachlan has defended the product, saying tote dividends are beating fixed odds in about 60 per cent of races.
The claims, side by side
- Betfair: BSP paid more than the One Pool win dividend on 70.7% of winners in its ten-day sample; in one cited race the tote returned $44 against $71 available at fixed odds
- Tabcorp: tote dividends beat fixed-odds prices in roughly 60% of races, on a smaller sample that included Flemington races commingled with the international World Pool
The two claims measure different things – Betfair compares its own exchange price against the tote, Tabcorp compares the tote against bookmaker fixed odds – so both can be arithmetically true at once. Each party also has a commercial interest in its own conclusion, and neither data set has been independently audited.
Why the gap exists
The structural difference is the fee model. One Pool deducts a 14.5 per cent takeout from win pools before dividends are declared. A betting exchange charges commission only on net winnings, so its headline price is trimmed less – though the BSP figure still overstates the net return, because commission comes off after the win. The gap tends to be widest on longer-priced runners, where pool percentages compound. Our explainer on house edge and takeout covers the mechanics.
Background
Tabcorp launched One Pool in early October, merging its three state totes into a single national pool. The company argued at launch that deeper pools would make dividends more stable. The first weeks of public data are now the test of that claim, and the exchange operator clearly sees a marketing opening.
For punters the practical check is simple: compare the declared tote dividend, the best available fixed price and the BSP on the same races you actually bet, over enough races to mean something. Ten days of spring racing is a start, not a verdict.
Sources
- Before You Bet: Betfair BSP beats TAB One Pool on 70% of winners
- Just Horse Racing: TAB boss defends One Pool
Bet only what you can afford to lose. Free, confidential support: Gambling Help Online, 1800 858 858.
Header photo: 2014 Super Saturday at Flemington racecourse by Chris Phutully, licensed CC BY 2.0.
